The Morality of Bargaining: Insights from “Caritas in Veritate”
نویسنده
چکیده
Pope Benedict XVI’s 2009 Encyclical-Letter ‘‘Caritas in Veritate,’’ (CV) breaks some new ground in the tradition of Catholic social teaching. I argue that explicitly this document makes a call for a new theory of economic exchange. Whereas, the traditional scholastic theory of the ‘‘just price’’ was focused on ‘‘the principle of the equivalence in value of exchanged goods’’ (CV 35), a new theory of exchange must focus instead on ‘‘a metaphysical understanding of the relations between persons’’ (CV 53). True, Thomas Aquinas pioneered this new approach to the morality of exchange when he argued that the Golden Rule must take precedence over the logic of the just price: the relation between persons must trump the relation between the goods exchanged. Caritas in Veritate argues further for a new theory of exchange that combines elements of mutual gain with elements of giftgiving. Here again we see a revision of traditional scholastic theory in which every transaction was defined exclusively either as a unilateral gift (subject to norms of distributive justice and charity) or as a bilateral exchange (subject to norms of commutative justice). Benedict, by contrast, calls for a vision of economic life in which giftgiving and exchange are mixed, so that bargains are ‘‘redolent with the spirit of gift’’ (CV 37) in a new ‘‘economy of gratuitousness’’ (CV 38). I propose to outline a new theory of exchange in which the elements of mutual gain and gift-giving are combined. To do so, I shall have to revise the traditional scholastic analysis of the just price, which was focused on the equality of the goods exchanged and instead focus on the moral equality of the parties to an exchange.
منابع مشابه
Caritas in Veritate , Work Still in Progress ?
remains as a complex, sometimes barely accessible but obvious masterpiece. It conveys this impressive feeling , commends several readings , each of them opening new avenues, not least because of its consistency with the needs of the present phase of historical global world development. As the E rightly points in its final chapter, the human social and political dilemma of to day has an anthropo...
متن کاملDoes Diversity Lead to Morality? On the Evolution of Strategies in a 3-Agent Alternating-Offers Bargaining Model
Experimental results with an alternating-offers bargaining model with agents that evolve strategies are described. Considerations are made on the relation between the distinct time preferences and the emergence of morality, in the form of convergence to fairer bargaining outcomes.
متن کاملDoes Scale of Public Hospitals Affect Bargaining Power? Evidence From Japan
Background Many of public hospitals in Japan have had a deficit for a long time. Japanese local governments have been encouraging public hospitals to use group purchasing of drugs to benefit from the economies of scale, and increase their bargaining power for obtaining discounts in drug purchasing, thus improving their financial situation. In this study, we empirically investigate whether or no...
متن کاملStructures of Virtue and Vice
The paper argues for new concepts in theological ethics: structures of virtue and structures of vice. The Catholic tradition’s development of the ‘structures of sin’ in the 1970’s and 80’s was a significant contribution to magisterial teaching. However, this concept should be updated in light of the trajectory and concepts of post-Vatican II theological ethics. The article proceeds in two parts...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2012